back to top
Tuesday, April 22, 2025

Why Is Elon Musk Still CEO of Tesla?

Share

Hello, and welcome to TechScape. In this week’s edition, we delve into the rollercoaster ride that is Elon Musk’s career. Despite a series of recent setbacks and growing public criticism, Musk remains at the helm of Tesla—an outcome that puzzles many industry watchers. Today, we examine the mounting challenges for both Musk and his marquee company, while also taking a look at how competitors like Apple and Meta are faring in their own tech battles.

A Series of Setbacks

The past ten days have marked some of the most significant setbacks for Elon Musk in months. Tesla’s stock has suffered a sharp decline, falling by 37% since the start of 2025. Investors are increasingly worried about a potential trade war, looming recession fears, and declining profits. Amid this financial storm, protests have erupted across the United States. Critics accuse Musk of using his influence to manipulate government policies, and his close ties with political figures have become a focal point of controversy.

READ MORE: Trump to Discuss Land and Power Plants with Putin in Ukraine Ceasefire Talks

Adding to the pressure, protests against Tesla have intensified, with vandalism and social stigma directed at the company’s vehicles. Outside Tesla service centers in cities like New Orleans, demonstrators have taken to the streets with signs calling for a boycott and demanding that Elon Musk be banned from government interactions. The fervor of these protests underscores a growing public discontent with Musk’s leadership style and his controversial public persona.

SpaceX and Social Media Woes

It’s not just Tesla that’s in the firing line. SpaceX, another one of Musk’s high-profile ventures, has also faced significant challenges. Last week, one of its rockets dramatically exploded in midflight, raising safety concerns and casting a shadow over its ambitious rescue mission to retrieve “stranded” astronauts—a mission that was delayed and then attempted again two days later. This mishap further dented investor confidence in Musk’s ability to manage multiple, high-stakes enterprises simultaneously.

Musk’s social media platform, X, also suffered widespread outages on Monday. During a Fox Business interview, Musk claimed that the disruptions were the result of a “massive cyberattack” traced to the Ukraine region. While the full details of the incident remain murky, the outage added another layer of complexity to an already tumultuous week for Musk.

Doge Drama and Political Pushback

In a twist that further complicates his public image, Musk’s involvement with his self-dubbed “first buddy,” Doge, has come under increasing scrutiny. Multiple reports indicate that Doge recently got into a heated exchange with US Secretary of State Marco Rubio during a White House meeting—a confrontation that ended with former President Donald Trump stepping in via a post on Truth Social to curtail Musk’s power over staffing decisions at government agencies. In addition, a federal judge in California issued a preliminary injunction on Thursday to reinstate thousands of workers that Doge had mass fired. Polling from Quinnipiac University suggests that, despite Musk’s repeated assertions that the public supports his Doge initiative, a strong majority of Americans disapprove of it.

The White House Sales Event and Trump’s Endorsement

In a bid to shore up his fortune amid these setbacks, Tesla held a high-profile sales event on the White House lawn. During the event, Donald Trump was seen browsing Tesla vehicles and ultimately announced he would purchase one, going so far as to label acts of vandalism against Tesla showrooms as domestic terrorism. While this presidential endorsement appears designed to reverse Musk’s string of losses and mitigate the backlash, it also paints a complex picture: Musk seems increasingly reliant on political figures like Trump to stabilize his financial fortunes and public image.

Yet, the move may not work as intended. Analysis from the New York Times reveals that Republicans tend to buy fewer electric vehicles compared to Democrats, and recent polls indicate that Democrats have developed a growing animosity toward Musk. As one analyst noted, “When you make your product unattractive to half the market, I promise you, you won’t increase your sales.” This division raises the question of whether Tesla’s board has a fiduciary duty to remove Musk in light of his declining stock value and the public controversies surrounding him.

The ongoing legal issues surrounding Musk further complicate his position at Tesla. In the past, shareholders have taken legal action over his enormous $56 billion pay package, and judges have ruled in favor of shareholders on multiple occasions. Despite these challenges, Musk remains in control because he is virtually synonymous with Tesla. To many investors, owning Tesla stock is as much an endorsement of Musk’s visionary approach as it is an investment in the company’s technology. The Cybertruck, for instance, has become as much a political symbol—an emblem of the MAGA movement—as it is a piece of cutting-edge automotive engineering.

A Broader Tech Landscape: Apple and Meta

While Musk grapples with his challenges at Tesla, other tech giants are experiencing their own struggles. Apple, once heralded for its sleek design and intuitive user interfaces, is facing harsh self-criticism over Siri’s persistent shortcomings. At last year’s company conference for software developers, Apple trumpeted significant upgrades to Siri. However, as internal sources later revealed, these enhancements failed to meet expectations. According to Bloomberg, Apple’s senior director, Robby Walker, described the shortcomings as “ugly and embarrassing,” a sentiment that led to the announcement of an indefinite delay on major updates to Siri.

The problem is that Siri, Apple’s digital assistant, has long been notorious for its ineptitude—often failing to execute even basic commands such as controlling Spotify accurately. With the advent of generative AI models like ChatGPT, Siri’s limitations have become even more apparent. Meanwhile, Apple Intelligence—a suite of features introduced alongside the iPhone 16—has generated viral confusion with its baffling summaries of notifications. In contrast, Amazon’s smart devices have recently been refreshed with enhancements powered by Anthropic’s Claude AI models, positioning Alexa as a more capable digital assistant.

Falling Short on AI: A Catastrophe in the Making

Apple’s inability to keep pace with rapid advancements in artificial intelligence has evolved into a full-blown catastrophe for the tech giant. For a company that prides itself on its superior design and innovation, the failure of Siri and related features is a major blow. As Wall Street and iPhone users alike await more substantial improvements, internal meetings and high-level reviews continue to cast doubt on Apple’s AI strategy. Senior leaders, including software chief Craig Federighi, have expressed concerns that the new AI functionalities not only fail to work as advertised but also lack the robustness needed for everyday use. Some in Apple’s AI division believe that the work on Siri’s new features should be scrapped entirely and restarted under fresh leadership.

The Resilience Factor

Despite the barrage of setbacks and controversies, one of the most striking aspects of Elon Musk’s continued tenure as CEO of Tesla is his ability to remain resilient. Even as Tesla’s stock falters and his ventures face significant headwinds, Musk’s brand—both as a visionary entrepreneur and a polarizing public figure—remains deeply embedded in the company’s identity. Shareholders continue to support him, largely because to own Tesla is to buy into Musk’s vision of a revolutionary future in electric vehicles and space exploration. This phenomenon, where the CEO is virtually inseparable from the company’s identity, makes it exceedingly difficult for the board to consider replacing him, despite his mounting challenges.

The Question of Leadership

Given the substantial decline in Tesla’s stock value and the ongoing controversies, some have questioned whether Musk’s continued leadership serves the best interests of the company. Legal challenges over his pay package and the persistent public relations issues add layers of complexity to the debate. However, as long as Musk is seen as the personification of Tesla’s innovative spirit, his position is likely to remain secure. His audacious approach and willingness to take risks, however controversial, have been key drivers of Tesla’s early successes. The company’s future, therefore, remains inextricably linked to his personal brand.

Final Thoughts: The Unyielding Force of Vision

In the world of high-stakes technology and innovation, Elon Musk continues to be a figure who both captivates and polarizes. His leadership at Tesla is a study in contrasts—a blend of visionary ambition, relentless risk-taking, and an uncanny ability to weather storms. Despite the challenges facing Tesla, SpaceX, and even his social media platform, Musk’s determination to forge ahead remains undiminished.

While Apple wrestles with its own internal challenges and falls short in the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence, Musk’s Tesla, with all its setbacks, still embodies the disruptive force that has reshaped the automotive industry. As the tech landscape continues to evolve, one thing is clear: leadership in this arena is as much about enduring public scrutiny and legal battles as it is about driving innovation. And for now, Elon Musk’s steadfast grip on Tesla appears unshakeable, even as he faces a barrage of challenges on multiple fronts.

Read more

Local News