Healthscope, one of Australia’s largest private hospital operators, has plunged into financial crisis this week after its investors entered receivership. The company’s 37 private hospitals across all states and territories—including Hobart Private Hospital, Darwin Private Hospital, and multiple facilities in Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland, and South Australia—face a cloud of uncertainty even as Healthscope assures patients and staff that “it is business as usual” .
Federal and state health authorities, insurers, and the Australian Medical Association (AMA) have all signaled concern about the potential fallout if any of Healthscope’s facilities were to close or scale back services. Patients who rely on Healthscope for timely elective and specialist care are already feeling anxious about possible disruptions to surgeries, specialist consultations, mental-health programs, and maternity services.
Patient Voices: Anxiety Over Delayed or Displaced Care
Cancer Survivor Fears Slower Surgery in Hobart
Vicki Purnell, a 65-year-old cancer survivor from Devonport, Tasmania, credits timely surgery at Hobart Private Hospital with saving her life. Diagnosed with a fast-growing uterine cancer in 2016, Purnell underwent curative surgery at Hobart Private within four days of referral—a turnaround she attributes to her private health cover. At the time, Royal Hobart Hospital waitlists for gynaecological oncology surgeries stretched weeks or months .
“I very quickly realised I had such swift surgery because I had private health insurance and I was able to go into Hobart Private, as opposed to waiting for a space at the Royal,” she said. “If I’d had to wait, the outcome might have been very different.”
The recent receivership announcement has Purnell worried that Hobart Private could close its doors or reduce capacity, forcing urgent cancer surgeries back onto the public waitlist. “If those cases shift to the Royal, there’s going to be a wait,” she said. “There’s only a finite amount of resources and operating-theatre time.”
Complex Chronic Care: “It Gives Me a Lot of Anxiety”
For 27-year-old Josie Mackey, Healthscope hospitals have provided essential support for chronic physical and mental health issues. Mackey travels between Tasmania and Victoria multiple times a year for specialist consultations, day procedures, and inpatient stays—services she says the public system could not accommodate.
“All of my specialists work out of Healthscope hospitals, and as someone with complex chronic health conditions, it gives me a lot of anxiety,” Mackey said. “It puts into question future surgeries and procedures—where will they be performed? Will my specialists move interstate or elsewhere?”
Mackey recalled that Healthscope’s former mental-health hospital in Hobart closed in 2023, displacing both patients and clinicians. She fears a repeat scenario if insolvency leads to further closures.
Maternity Services at Risk in Darwin and Hobart
Expectant mother Jess McClusky is equally unsettled. The Darwin Private Hospital, Healthscope’s only private maternity facility in the Northern Territory, will cease obstetric services next week. From August, Hobart Private will also suspend maternity care—leaving both jurisdictions without private birth suites .
“It’s a waste of money—if you’re paying for insurance and you can’t get anything for it, what’s the point?” McClusky asked. “We’re keeping our cover until we’ve had this baby, then we’ll reconsider.”
McClusky fears that Darwin’s overcapacity public hospital could struggle to absorb private patients, especially during peak seasons when bed shortages and staffing constraints are most acute.
The Private-Public Balance: Elective Surgery and System Strain
Australia’s healthcare model relies on private hospitals to deliver over two-thirds of elective surgeries, relieving pressure on public hospitals that provide the bulk of emergency and specialist care. According to the AMA, roughly 70 percent of planned procedures occur in private facilities; these include orthopaedic joint replacements, cataract operations, and many oncology and cardiac interventions .
When private hospitals close or scale back, public hospitals must pick up the slack, lengthening waitlists and stretching already limited resources. In Tasmania, where two of only three gynaecological oncologists split their time between public and private, the loss of private capacity could delay critical cancer surgeries. In Darwin, the cessation of private maternity care and day-surgery suites threatens to divert high-risk births and gynaecological procedures into the overburdened Royal Darwin Hospital.
Doctors’ Perspectives: Reassessing Private Health Value
AMA President Dr Danielle McMullen underscores the private sector’s essential role in maintaining nationwide healthcare capacity.
“Our dual system is unique and contributes to world-leading outcomes,” she said. “When private hospitals close, regional communities lose not only beds but often their specialist doctors, who can no longer sustain a private practice and may relocate. That further deprives public hospitals of experienced clinicians.”
McMullen warned that receivership would prompt many policyholders to question the value of private health insurance. “If consumers can’t access the services they pay for, they will reconsider their cover,” she said. “Governments, insurers, and private providers must collaborate—perhaps under a dedicated private-health authority—to ensure system stability and safeguard patient access.”
Economic Pressures and Policy Implications
Healthscope’s financial collapse follows a controversial leveraged buyout in 2021, leaving the company saddled with debt and rising interest costs amid cost-of-living pressures. Rising wages, energy expenses, and supply-chain disruptions have compounded operating costs for private hospitals nationwide.
Health economists caution that without reforms—such as indexed rebates for private insurers, targeted subsidies for regional facilities, or a panel-style funding model—other private operators may face similar insolvency risks. A 2024 government review recommended stronger co-investment between states and the private sector, particularly for rural and remote hospitals where margins are already tight.
Patient Advocacy and Government Response
Consumer advocacy groups are urging immediate action. The Private Hospitals Australia lobby calls for interim government support—akin to a liquidity lifeline—to ensure no abrupt closures. Meanwhile, the National Rural Health Commissioner stresses the need to preserve private hospital networks in regional areas, where they often fill gaps in ambulance, imaging, and specialist outreach services .
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler has committed to monitoring the situation closely, stating, “We will not allow patients to be left stranded. I am in discussion with state health ministers, insurers, and Healthscope’s receivers to explore all options, including bridging finance or temporary service agreements.”
What Patients Can Do: Planning and Precautions
While private hospitals continue normal operations, patients with scheduled procedures at Healthscope facilities are advised to:
- Stay Informed: Monitor official communications from Healthscope and their treating specialists for any changes to service availability or admissions processes.
- Confirm Dates: Double-check booking confirmations and pre-admission instructions with both the hospital and surgeon’s rooms.
- Review Insurance: Speak with health insurers about alternative provider networks or coverage extensions if Healthscope services become unavailable.
- Explore Public Options: Early consultation with public hospital teams may secure waitlist positions, should private capacity be reduced.
- Seek Case Management: Specialist nurses and patient-liaison officers can help coordinate cross-facility transfers and access to supportive care.
Looking Ahead: Uncertain Future, Urgent Need for Reform
Healthscope’s receivership has laid bare the fragility of Australia’s private hospital sector and its critical interdependence with public services. For patients like Vicki Purnell, Josie Mackey, and Jess McClusky, the prospect of delayed surgeries, relocated specialists, and lost continuity of care is deeply distressing.
As Healthscope’s receivers work to stabilise finances and explore sale or restructure options, governments and industry bodies face a pivotal decision: whether to shore up the private system through targeted policy changes or risk further hospital closures that could reverberate through the entire healthcare network.
In the weeks ahead, the fate of Healthscope hospitals—and the thousands of patients who rely on them—will serve as a litmus test for the resilience of Australia’s mixed-public-private healthcare model. The choices made now will determine not only the future of a single provider but the security of elective and specialist care for communities from Hobart to Darwin.
READ MORE: Investment in Big Batteries Surges as Australia Accelerates Energy Transition
