Just weeks after the Oscars celebrated Anora as Best Picture, awards season pivots toward television with the Gotham TV Awards 2025. As the newly established counterpart to the long-running Gotham Film Awards, the TV ceremony shines a spotlight on series that premiered between June 1, 2024, and May 31, 2025—an eligibility window identical to that of the forthcoming Emmys. Created to recognize and celebrate brand-new shows rather than returning favorites, the Gotham TV Awards open the door for emerging talents, breakthrough limited series, and fresh creative voices. This year, Netflix’s limited series Adolescence swept multiple categories, while celebrated creators such as Hwang Dong-hyuk, Amy Sherman-Palladino, and David E. Kelley received coveted Tributes. Below is a comprehensive look at the winners, standout moments, and the broader significance of this year’s Gotham TV Awards.
What Are the Gotham TV Awards? Redefining “Breakthrough” in TV
• Origins and Purpose
Before 2024, the Gotham Awards encompassed both film and television. This year marked the second standalone Gotham TV Awards ceremony, designed exclusively for shows debuting within a single eligibility period. By excluding returning series, the awards prioritize creative risk-takers and title-makers whose first seasons captivated critics, peers, and audiences alike. In doing so, the Gotham TV Awards offer an early barometer for the Emmys, highlighting drama series, comedies, limited series, non-fiction programming, and individual performances that stand apart in a crowded streaming ecosystem.
• Emmy Alignment and Industry Impact
As Gotham TV Awards Executive Director Catherine Rooney has noted, “Our eligibility dates mirror the Emmys, making the Gotham TV Awards a predictive guide to which series and performances may carry momentum into summer and fall voting.” The limited—yet highly selective—field of nominees ensures that each title receives focused attention, from narrative innovators to breakout actors. Industry insiders often track Gotham’s winners and nominees to gauge how the Emmys race might unfold, and this year’s ceremony reaffirmed Gotham’s place at the vanguard of awards season.
Adolescence: The Breakthrough Limited Series of 2025
• Plot, Themes, and Global Impact
Released as a Netflix limited series in late 2024, Adolescence followed a suburban town’s unraveling when a teenage boy stands accused of murdering a classmate. Co-created by Stephen Graham and Anna Jameson, the six-episode thriller delved into radical misogyny, online incel communities, and escalating violence. Shot in a single continuous take, the series demanded both technical mastery and uncompromising performances from its young cast. Audiences and critics praised its visceral cinematography and unflinching exploration of toxic masculinity, sparking worldwide discussion among parents, educators, and mental health advocates.
• Gotham Victories
At the Gotham TV Awards, Adolescence garnered three awards:
– Breakthrough Limited Series
– Outstanding Lead Performance in a Limited Series (Stephen Graham as Detective Alastair Connolly)
– Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Limited Series (Owen Cooper as Jamie Miller; tied with Jenny Slate in Dying for Sex)
Co-creator Stephen Graham accepted his award via a heartfelt video message, noting, “We set out to challenge the conventions of crime drama—and to show that a small, singular story, handled with love and respect, can resonate across oceans. Tonight’s recognition proves that audiences respond to authenticity.” Fifteen-year-old breakout star Owen Cooper, who embodied accused teen Jamie Miller, thanked co-star Erin Doherty, who also received a nomination, saying, “Our harrowing scenes together were possible because of your trust and talent. I share this with Jenny Slate, who delivered such a raw, unsparing performance in Dying for Sex.”
Acting Awards: Recognizing Lead and Supporting Performances
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Limited Series
– Winner: Stephen Graham, Adolescence
– Nominees included Brian Tyree Henry (Dope Thief), Cristin Milioti (The Penguin), Megan Stott (Penelope), Michelle Williams (Dying for Sex).
Stephen Graham’s portrayal of Detective Connolly—a father torn between justice and understanding his son’s radicalization—earned praise for its emotional complexity. Each nominee brought a distinct style: Brian Tyree Henry’s volatile, charismatic turn in Dope Thief, Cristin Milioti’s empathy in the noir-inspired The Penguin, Megan Stott’s steely determination in Penelope, and Michelle Williams’s nuanced vulnerability in Dying for Sex.
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Limited Series
– Winners (tie): Owen Cooper, Adolescence and Jenny Slate, Dying for Sex
– Nominees included Erin Doherty (Adolescence), Taraji P. Henson (Fight Night: The Million Dollar Heist), Diego Luna (La Máquina).
Owen Cooper’s chilling depiction of a teenager both victim and perpetrator, combined with Jenny Slate’s unflinching comedic-drama balance in Dying for Sex, marked a rare tie in Gotham history. Cooper and Slate each credited co-stars and writers, underscoring the collaborative nature of limited series development.
Breaking Ground: Comedy and Drama Series of the Year
Breakthrough Comedy Series
– Winner: The Studio (Futurist Productions)
– Nominees: #1 Happy Family USA, English Teacher, Fantasmas, Overcompensating.
Set in a failing early-2000s production house, The Studio follows a crew of neurotic creatives compelled to produce a low-budget reality show while contending with personal eccentricities. Critics lauded its razor-sharp satire of media culture and spot-on period details, from flip phones to Boy Band tantrums. Creator–star Miriam Chen dedicated the win to “anyone who’s tried to follow a dream, only to end up in a cramped studio with too many cables and not enough coffee.”
Breakthrough Drama Series
– Winner: The Pitt (Pinewood Collective)
– Nominees: Black Doves, Forever, Matlock, One Hundred Years of Solitude.
Set in a near-future metropolis devastated by economic collapse, The Pitt portrayed a vaccine-resistant viral outbreak superimposed on gang uprisings. With taut storytelling and gritty cinematography, the series unfolded over eight episodes, tying societal commentary to visceral character arcs. Showrunner Sanjay Rao accepted the award alongside principal cast, emphasizing the importance of reflecting real-world anxieties through speculative fiction.
Comparisons to Past Winners
In 2024, Baby Reindeer swept Breakthrough Limited Series at Gotham and went on to win Outstanding Limited Series at the Emmys. Industry observers view Adolescence as a similarly strong contender for the 2025 Emmys. Likewise, The Studio’s launch of a star-studded cast and archival aesthetic recalled 2023’s The Bear, another Gotham breakout that garnered Emmy buzz.
Celebrating Non-Fiction and Genre-Bending Storytelling
Breakthrough Non-Fiction Series
– Winner: Social Studies (Arcadia Films)
– Nominees: Conbody Vs Everybody, Hollywood Black, Omnivore, Ren Faire.
Social Studies follows high school students navigating digital activism, mental health crises, and generational divides. Blending vérité-style interviews with immersive cinematography, the series subverts typical docuseries tropes by centering youth voices in political discourse. Executive Producer Elena Vasquez accepted the award, saying, “Our subjects taught us that social media can be as powerful as any protest. I dedicate this to them, to keep speaking truth to power.”
Outstanding Lead Performances: Comedy and Drama
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Comedy Series
– Winner: Julio Torres (Fantasmas)
– Nominees: Ted Danson (A Man on the Inside), Anna Lambe (North of North), Saagar Shaikh (Deli Boys), Benito Skinner (Overcompensating).
Comedian Julio Torres delivered a magical-realism tour de force in Fantasmas, co-creating a whimsical Los Angeles where ghosts offer spiritual life lessons. Torres’s deadpan wit and surrealist flair impressed Gotham jurors. He accepted the award live in L.A., quipping, “I only speak ghost… and Spanish. Obrigado!”
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Drama Series
– Winner: Kathy Bates (Matlock)
– Nominees: Sterling K. Brown (Paradise), Aldis Hodge (Cross), Lovie Simone (Forever), Noah Wyle (The Pitt).
In an unexpected reboot, Matlock reimagined the 1980s legal drama as a high-stakes courtroom thriller set in present-day Gotham City. As Judge Fiona Matlock, Oscar-winner Kathy Bates anchored the show’s emotional core. In her acceptance speech, she reflected on career milestones: “From Dr. Lecter to Matlock fields, the law has become my latest fascination. This role challenged me to be both empathetic and unflinching, and I’m truly grateful for Gotham’s recognition.”
Outstanding Supporting Performances: Comedy and Drama
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Comedy Series
– Winner: Poorna Jagannathan (Deli Boys)
– Nominees: Linda Lavin (Mid-Century Modern), Sean Patton (English Teacher), Timothy Simons (Nobody Wants This), Chase Sui Wonders (The Studio).
Deli Boys chronicles three New York City South Asians who inherit a family delicatessen and promptly descend into petty crime to keep it afloat. Jagannathan’s manic, fearless portrayal of the family matriarch-turned-crime-kingpin garnered raucous applause. “Playing a character who’s allergic to failure taught me more than any drama,” she joked.
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Drama Series
– Winner: Ben Whishaw (Black Doves)
– Nominees: Katherine LaNasa (The Pitt), James Marsden (Paradise), Skye P. Marshall (Matlock), Olivia Williams (Dune: Prophecy).
In a kinetic espionage drama set on the frozen tundra, Black Doves explored Arctic geopolitics via a covert British agent (Ben Whishaw) reluctant to betray his own identity. Whishaw’s mesmerizing performance—as both stoic operative and vulnerable human—resonated with jurors. He dedicated his win to “my fellow spies, both real and fictional,” adding a touch of levity to the solemn subject matter.
Expanding Horizons: Film, Broadcast, and Streaming
Outstanding Original Film, Broadcast or Streaming
– Winner: Pee-wee as Himself (Neon Pictures)
– Nominees: Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy, Ladies & Gentlemen… 50 Years of SNL Music, Rebel Ridge, Sly Lives! (aka The Burden of Black Genius).
The documentary Pee-wee as Himself chronicled the cultural legacy of Pee-wee Herman, blending archival footage of Paul Reubens’s 1980s persona with interviews featuring Tim Burton, Kristen Wiig, and John Waters. Director Jessica Kim celebrated the award as “proof that we can reexamine nostalgia for deeper truths—how a children’s TV host became a queer icon in the ’90s.” Actor Aaron Pierre won Outstanding Performance in an Original Film for his nuanced turn in the indie thriller Rebel Ridge, depicting an ex-Military contractor entangled in a political conspiracy.
Special Honors: Tributes to Industry Trailblazers
Legend Tribute: Parker Posey
Honored by co-stars Leslie Bibb and Sam Rockwell, Parker Posey received the inaugural Legend Tribute for her dynamic role as Victoria Ratcliff in The White Lotus: Thailand. Bibb praised Posey as the “Quintessential queen of indie film and satirical comedy,” while Rockwell lauded her fearless range. In her acceptance, Posey thanked writer–director Mike White for “believing in a middle-aged woman with a wicked sense of humor.” The Legend Tribute acknowledges performers whose enduring body of work has shaped television’s cultural landscape.
Sidney Poitier Icon Tribute: Sheryl Lee Ralph
Sheryl Lee Ralph’s searing, scene-stealing role as Principal Barbara Howard on Abbott Elementary earned her praise from Gotham President Marcia Levy, who spoke of Ralph’s “commitment to representation and comedic timing.” In accepting, Ralph recalled Sidney Poitier’s advice early in her career: “When he cast me in A Piece of the Action (1977), he told me, ‘Sheryl Lee Ralph, you will do great things.’ Tonight, I am living that possibility thanks to you, Sidney. I’ll keep the arts alive in his honor.” Ralph’s Emmy win in 2022—making her the first Black woman in 35 years to claim Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Comedy—reinforced her Icon status.
Creator Tribute: Hwang Dong-hyuk (Squid Game)
Awarded by series star Lee Jung-jae, Hwang Dong-hyuk accepted the Creator Tribute for his groundbreaking global phenomenon Squid Game. Lee praised Hwang’s “meticulous world-building and social critique,” which humanized survivors in a savage, dystopian competition. In his acceptance, Hwang thanked both fans and critics who initially rejected his concept in 2009: “If any of you had said ‘yes’ back then, there would be no Squid Game as it exists today. I learned more from your ‘no’s than any praise.” The Creator Tribute honors showrunners and writers whose vision transforms television narratives and global discourse.
Performer Tribute: Brian Tyree Henry (Dope Thief)
Brian Tyree Henry received the Performer Tribute for his dual work in Dope Thief and various film projects, demonstrating range from intense drama to offbeat comedy. Gotham Board Member Stacey Baker noted Henry’s “ability to vanish into any role” while still remaining fully present. Henry accepted with gratitude, promising to continue pushing creative boundaries.
Ensemble Tribute: Elisabeth Moss and The Handmaid’s Tale Cast
Elisabeth Moss led The Handmaid’s Tale ensemble onto the Gotham stage to receive the inaugural Ensemble Tribute. Moss, clutching a miniature golden lotus, praised co-stars Alexis Bledel, Yvonne Strahovski, Joseph Fiennes, and the entire cast: “Working on The Handmaid’s Tale feels like building a fortress of resistance every day.” This collective honor recognizes a cast whose collaborative synergy and unified message against authoritarianism elevated episodic television to social commentary.
Spotlight on Diversity, Inclusion, and the Future of TV
Women to the Forefront
Several attendees and winners underscored the importance of diverse voices in front of and behind the camera. Overcompensating opening host Mary Beth Barone quipped, “We celebrate so many talented artists—and yes, some men, too.” Poorna Jagannathan’s acceptance for Deli Boys cited the joy of portraying “brown characters who aren’t beholden to any message—just pure, messy, hilarious humanity.” Similarly, Parker Posey, Sheryl Lee Ralph, and Amy Sherman-Palladino reminded viewers that television must reflect all identities, from genre storytellers to comedians, from Indigenous voices to LGBTQ+ creatives.
Global Television as Activism
Hwang Dong-hyuk’s Squid Game and Adolescence both exemplify a broader trend of television that confronts pressing societal issues—economic inequality, online radicalization, gender-based violence—on a global stage. Gotham jurors deliberately honored series that “spark conversations beyond living rooms,” echoing a sense that television’s potential extends far beyond entertainment to activism and social change.
Looking Ahead: Emmys and the Road Beyond Gotham
Emmy Predictions and Momentum
Historically, Gotham TV winners and nominees often propel onto Emmy ballots: Baby Reindeer (2024 Breakthrough Limited Series) took home Outstanding Limited Series at the 2024 Emmys. Similarly, Adolescence’s sweep and critical acclaim position it as a presumptive Emmy nominee for Outstanding Limited Series. Stephen Graham, Owen Cooper, and Jenny Slate likely will see their Gotham statuettes followed by Emmy nom plaques this summer. In comedy and drama, Julio Torres (Fantasmas), Poorna Jagannathan (Deli Boys), and Ben Whishaw (Black Doves) join a competitive pack of performers vying for Emmy recognition.
The Continued Evolution of the Gotham Awards
As Gotham’s TV branch matures, its unique focus on debut seasons and fresh creativity will likely attract more international submissions. Executive Director Catherine Rooney suggests a future expansion of categories to include writing, directing, and technical achievements. Additionally, discussions are underway to livestream the Awards in multiple time zones, reflecting the global interest in television innovation.
Fan Engagement and Online Fandoms
Fans continue to debate Gotham winners on Reddit threads and Twitter hashtags, dissecting every performance nuance. “When a series breaks through, like Adolescence or The Studio, the fans form micro-communities—creating memes about Stephen Graham’s single-take monologues or sharing clips of Julio Torres’s surrealist humor,” Montgomery says of the fan culture around Gotham-recognized shows. This fan engagement reinforces the awards’ relevance, forging connections between creators and audiences.
Conclusion: Celebrating Television’s Reinvention
The Gotham TV Awards 2025 underscored a pivotal moment in television—where fresh voices, global perspectives, and boundary-pushing formats converge. Adolescence’s critical triumph demonstrated that intimate, locally rooted stories can resonate worldwide; Fantasmas and Deli Boys highlighted the power of comedy to explore cultural identity; and creator tributes to Hwang Dong-hyuk, Amy Sherman-Palladino, David E. Kelley, and Sheryl Lee Ralph honored architects of enduring narratives.
As the red carpets settle and winners return to pressing forward on new projects, one thing is clear: Television’s “breakthrough” spirit remains vital. The Gotham TV Awards not only crown the year’s most innovative series but also inspire future creators to take bold risks. In the words of Gotham CEO Marcia Levy, “We celebrate storytelling that unsettles, entertains, and challenges—all while recognizing the collaborative artistry that brings these shows to life.”
Full List of Gotham TV Award Winners 2025
Breakthrough Comedy Series
• Winner: The Studio
• Nominees: #1 Happy Family USA, English Teacher, Fantasmas, Overcompensating
Breakthrough Drama Series
• Winner: The Pitt
• Nominees: Black Doves, Forever, Matlock, One Hundred Years of Solitude
Breakthrough Limited Series
• Winner: Adolescence
• Nominees: Dying for Sex, Get Millie Back, Penelope, Say Nothing
Breakthrough Non-Fiction Series
• Winner: Social Studies
• Nominees: Conbody Vs Everybody, Hollywood Black, Omnivore, Ren Faire
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Comedy Series
• Winner: Julio Torres, Fantasmas
• Nominees: Ted Danson (A Man on the Inside), Anna Lambe (North of North), Saagar Shaikh (Deli Boys), Benito Skinner (Overcompensating)
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Drama Series
• Winner: Kathy Bates, Matlock
• Nominees: Sterling K. Brown (Paradise), Aldis Hodge (Cross), Lovie Simone (Forever), Noah Wyle (The Pitt)
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Limited Series
• Winner: Stephen Graham, Adolescence
• Nominees: Brian Tyree Henry (Dope Thief), Cristin Milioti (The Penguin), Megan Stott (Penelope), Michelle Williams (Dying for Sex)
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Comedy Series
• Winner: Poorna Jagannathan, Deli Boys
• Nominees: Linda Lavin (Mid-Century Modern), Sean Patton (English Teacher), Timothy Simons (Nobody Wants This), Chase Sui Wonders (The Studio)
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Drama Series
• Winner: Ben Whishaw, Black Doves
• Nominees: Katherine LaNasa (The Pitt), James Marsden (Paradise), Skye P. Marshall (Matlock), Olivia Williams (Dune: Prophecy)
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Limited Series
• Winners (tie): Owen Cooper (Adolescence) and Jenny Slate (Dying for Sex)
• Nominees: Erin Doherty (Adolescence), Taraji P. Henson (Fight Night: The Million Dollar Heist), Diego Luna (La Máquina)
Outstanding Original Film, Broadcast or Streaming
• Winner: Pee-wee as Himself
• Nominees: Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy, Ladies & Gentlemen… 50 Years of SNL Music, Rebel Ridge, Sly Lives! (aka The Burden of Black Genius)
Outstanding Performance in an Original Film
• Winner: Aaron Pierre, Rebel Ridge
• Nominees: Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor (The Supremes at Earl’s All-You-Can-Eat), Dylan O’Brien (Caddo Lake), Phoebe-Rae Taylor (Out of My Mind), Renée Zellweger (Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy)
Tribute Honorees
• Legend Tribute: Parker Posey, The White Lotus: Thailand
• Sidney Poitier Icon Tribute: Sheryl Lee Ralph, Abbott Elementary
• Creator Tribute: Hwang Dong-hyuk, Squid Game
• Creator Tribute: David E. Kelley, Presumed Innocent
• Creator Tribute: Amy Sherman-Palladino & Daniel Palladino, Étoile
• Performer Tribute: Brian Tyree Henry, Dope Thief
• Ensemble Tribute: Elisabeth Moss & cast, The Handmaid’s Tale
As the Gotham TV Awards continue to champion bold, new television, their 2025 winners list reminds us that the next era of small-screen storytelling thrives on risk, innovation, and fearless performances—setting the stage for what promises to be an electrifying Emmy season.
READ MORE: Jason Sudeikis Reflects on the “Incredible Influence” of Late Uncle George Wendt
