A new study from the University of Jyväskylä in Finland reveals that the everyday physical activities most women engage in are insufficient to counteract the accelerated bone loss driven by hormonal changes during menopause. Researchers warn that while regular movement is beneficial for overall health, the typical impacts of daily life do not provide the targeted bone-loading necessary to slow the weakening of bones that accompanies the menopausal transition.
Understanding Menopausal Bone Loss
Menopause brings significant hormonal changes that result in accelerated bone weakening—a process that increases the risk of osteoporosis and fractures. Previous research has demonstrated that weight-bearing, impact-loading exercises, and high-intensity strength training can positively influence bone density. Even short bursts of high-intensity activity have been shown to benefit bone health by stimulating bone remodeling and strengthening. However, until now, little was known about whether the natural, habitual impacts accumulated during everyday activities could similarly mitigate the hormonal bone loss experienced during menopause.
The Study Design and Participant Profile
The research, part of the larger ERMA study conducted between 2015 and 2018, followed 189 perimenopausal women aged between 47 and 55 from Jyväskylä until they reached postmenopause. Menopausal stages were determined using a combination of blood hormone levels and detailed menstrual diaries, ensuring that the researchers could accurately track each participant’s transition. The follow-up period averaged about 15 months, during which participants’ everyday physical activities were meticulously recorded using wearable accelerometers.
READ MORE: 5 Easy Ways to Reduce Your Microplastic Intake
The accelerometers were used to measure the number and intensity of bone-loading impacts—those moments when weight-bearing activities, such as walking, stair climbing, or even light jogging, put stress on the bones. In addition to tracking physical activity, the study measured bone mineral density (BMD) at critical skeletal sites. Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) was used to assess BMD at the narrowest point of the femoral neck, while computed tomography (CT) scans provided detailed measurements of bone density and structural properties in the femoral and tibial shafts for a subset of 61 women.
Key Findings: The Limits of Daily Movement
Despite the participants’ engagement in everyday physical activities, the study found that the typical, unstructured bone-loading encountered during daily routines did not significantly slow the hormonal bone loss associated with menopause. Dr. Tuuli Suominen, one of the study’s lead researchers, explained:
“We observed that while moderate-intensity impacts did show a positive association with bone strength at the femoral and tibial shafts, these natural impacts are simply not frequent or intense enough in everyday life to counteract the rapid bone mineral density loss triggered by menopause.”
The study showed that while there was some improvement in bone strength at specific sites with increased activity, these gains were marginal and insufficient to halt the overall process of bone weakening. In other words, while regular physical activity is undoubtedly important for health, it does not provide the kind of targeted, high-impact loading necessary to combat the effects of reduced estrogen levels during menopause.
Why Everyday Impacts Fall Short
One of the study’s most critical insights is that effective bone-loading requires more than just regular movement—it demands activities that create high-magnitude forces on the bone. These forces stimulate bone remodeling, a process by which bones rebuild and strengthen themselves in response to stress. However, in everyday life, most activities do not generate the necessary level of mechanical strain. The research highlighted that high-intensity impacts, which are more commonly seen in structured exercise programs, are rare during routine daily activities.
Dr. Suominen elaborated, saying:
“Our bodies need specific, high-impact activities to really trigger the mechanisms that fortify bones. While everyday movements like walking are excellent for cardiovascular health and general mobility, they often fall short when it comes to delivering the high forces required to maintain or improve bone density during the hormonal upheavals of menopause.”
Implications for Osteoporosis Prevention
These findings carry significant implications for the prevention of osteoporosis, a disease characterized by fragile bones and an increased risk of fractures. With millions of women worldwide entering menopause each year, the study underscores the need for more targeted exercise interventions that specifically address bone health. Current recommendations often stress general physical activity, but the evidence from this research suggests that women might need to incorporate more structured, high-impact or resistance training exercises into their routines to effectively counter menopausal bone loss.
The study suggests that healthcare providers should consider advising menopausal women not only to stay active but to engage in specific bone-loading exercises. These might include activities like jumping, resistance training, or other forms of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) that are known to produce the necessary mechanical strain on bones.
Recommendations for Future Research
While the University of Jyväskylä study provides valuable insights, it also highlights several areas for further investigation. The researchers call for future studies to explore whether tailored, high-impact exercise regimens can slow the progression of hormonal bone loss during menopause more effectively than everyday physical activity alone.
Dr. Suominen noted:
“We need to understand more about the specific types, intensities, and durations of exercise that could offer significant protective benefits for bone health during menopause. Future research should focus on designing and testing targeted exercise programs that can be safely implemented by women in the perimenopausal and postmenopausal stages.”
Additionally, further studies are necessary to determine the long-term effects of these specialized exercise regimens on bone mineral density, fracture risk, and overall skeletal health. Such research could lead to updated public health guidelines and more effective prevention strategies for osteoporosis.
The Role of Technology in Monitoring Bone Health
Advancements in wearable technology and non-invasive imaging techniques may play a crucial role in this research. By using accelerometers, DXA scans, and CT imaging, researchers can gain a more precise understanding of how different types of physical activity affect bone strength over time. These technologies not only provide data for scientific studies but also have the potential to help individuals monitor their own bone health more closely.
For instance, future devices could be developed to measure the intensity of bone-loading impacts in real time, offering personalized exercise recommendations to help women optimize their bone health during menopause. Integrating these monitoring tools into fitness trackers could revolutionize how women manage their skeletal health, providing actionable insights and tailored exercise programs based on individual needs.
A Call to Action for Health Practitioners and Policymakers
The findings of this study serve as an urgent reminder to both health practitioners and policymakers. There is a pressing need to revisit current exercise recommendations for menopausal women and to consider integrating more specific guidelines for bone-loading activities into public health strategies.
Healthcare providers should encourage women to participate in high-impact or resistance exercises and consider referring patients to physiotherapists or exercise specialists who can design tailored programs. Moreover, public health campaigns could play a vital role in educating women about the limitations of everyday physical activity in preventing bone loss during menopause, emphasizing the importance of structured exercise as part of a comprehensive osteoporosis prevention strategy.
Conclusion: Redefining Physical Activity for Menopausal Health
The University of Jyväskylä study challenges the conventional wisdom that everyday physical activity is sufficient to protect against menopausal bone loss. While staying active remains critical for overall health, the research indicates that the mechanical demands of routine movement are often too low to stimulate significant bone remodeling in the face of hormonal changes.
As the scientific community continues to investigate the complex interplay between exercise and bone health during menopause, there is hope that more targeted and effective exercise interventions will be developed. In the meantime, menopausal women and their healthcare providers must recognize that while a daily walk is beneficial, it may need to be complemented with high-intensity, bone-loading exercises to ensure optimal skeletal health.
This study not only highlights the challenges posed by menopausal bone loss but also paves the way for innovative approaches to osteoporosis prevention, ultimately aiming to improve the quality of life for millions of women worldwide.
