In a groundbreaking experiment that bridges geology, chemistry and biology, researchers in Germany have simulated the primordial conditions of Earth’s early oceans—and in doing so they have demonstrated that the chemical reactions thought to have powered the planet’s first living cells can indeed occur without enzymes. Mimicking the iron-rich, hydrogen-spewing environment around so-called “black smoker” hydrothermal vents, the team led by geochemist Vanessa Helmbrecht of Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich showed that Methanocaldococcus jannaschii, an ancient single-celled microbe of the Archaea domain, not only survived but grew exponentially when confined to a miniature chemical garden. The results offer compelling evidence that hydrothermal vents served as natural incubators for life’s first metabolic pathways nearly four billion years ago.
Background: The Ancient Hydrothermal Hypothesis
The quest to understand how life emerged on a barren early Earth has long centered on hydrothermal vents—fissures on the ocean floor that discharge superheated fluids rich in hydrogen, iron and sulfur. These vents, first discovered in the 1970s, support ecosystems that thrive without sunlight, instead deriving energy from chemical reactions between vent fluids and surrounding seawater. Geochemical studies suggest that similar vents existed as early as four billion years ago, during the Archaean eon, when Earth’s oceans contained far more dissolved iron than they do today.
READ MORE: Allen Institute Launches CellScapes to Decode How Cells Cooperate
Historical records of black smoker chimneys, formed by precipitation of iron sulfide minerals, coincide with the oldest putative fossils of life on Earth. The prevailing theory—known as the “hydrothermal hypothesis”—posits that mineral-laden structures called chemical gardens created natural electrochemical gradients and catalytic surfaces that could drive carbon fixation, the process by which inorganic carbon dioxide is converted into the organic compounds essential for life.
Key to this scenario is the acetyl coenzyme A (acetyl CoA) pathway, the only known method of carbon fixation that can proceed abiotically, without enzymes. Modern deep-sea archaea and bacteria still rely on variants of this pathway, suggesting a direct lineage between today’s vent-dwelling microbes and the very first living cells.
Experiment Design: Simulating Primordial Ocean Conditions
To test whether abiotic reactions in iron-sulfide chemical gardens could support life, Helmbrecht and her colleagues recreated ancient seawater in the laboratory. They prepared a deoxygenated solution rich in dissolved iron—reflecting Archaean ocean chemistry—and injected it with a sulfidic fluid under anoxic conditions. Within minutes, the reaction produced a black precipitate of iron sulfide minerals, forming chimney-like structures analogous to natural black smokers.
The minerals formed included mackinawite (FeS) and greigite (Fe₃S₄), both known to catalyze redox reactions. When hydrated, these minerals release molecular hydrogen (H₂), a key electron donor in early metabolic processes. By adjusting temperature and fluid flow rates to approximate vent conditions—250–300°C at the chimney walls and 100–120°C at the outer surfaces—the researchers generated a dynamic microenvironment in which redox gradients could emerge.
Into this artificial vent system the team introduced Methanocaldococcus jannaschii, a hydrogen-utilizing archaeon originally isolated from a natural hydrothermal vent off Mexico’s Pacific coast. M. jannaschii is known to fix carbon using the reductive acetyl CoA pathway, consuming H₂ and CO₂ to grow. Crucially, its pathway requires no enzymes, only simple transition-metal catalysts—making it the perfect modern proxy for ancient metabolisms.
Results: Exponential Growth in a Vial
Contrary to expectations that growth would be marginal in a minimal, enzyme-free system, M. jannaschii cells proliferated rapidly. Over a 48-hour period, cell counts near the mackinawite particles increased by more than tenfold. Gene-expression analyses confirmed over-expression of key acetyl CoA pathway genes, indicating active carbon fixation.
Microscopic observations revealed that cells clustered at the mineral interface, where hydrogen production was highest. Electron microscopy captured archaea adhering to corkscrew-shaped mineral filaments, closely resembling fossilized microbial remains found in Archaean rock formations. The congruence between experimental and geological evidence suggests that early life might have colonized natural chemical gardens in much the same way.
Helmbrecht remarked, “We expected only slight growth without supplemental nutrients, vitamins or trace metals. Instead, we saw a robust microbial response, driven solely by the intrinsic redox chemistry of iron-sulfide minerals.” Co-author Dr. Felix Baumgartner added, “This is the first time we’ve directly linked abiotic H₂ production to biologically relevant growth in a system that faithfully reproduces primordial vent conditions.”
Implications: Mackinawite and Greigite as Life’s Cradle
The success of these experiments positions mackinawite and greigite chemical gardens as prime candidates for life’s original hatcheries. In natural hydrothermal systems, mineral chimneys offer vast surface areas and steep redox gradients, creating microenvironments where simple cells could derive energy and carbon. Over time, these communities may have evolved more complex metabolisms, eventually giving rise to the diversity of life seen today.
Professor William Fischer, a leading origin-of-life researcher not involved in the study, called the work “a stunning demonstration that key metabolic steps can occur in the absence of biological catalysts, supporting the idea that vent-based chemistries laid the groundwork for evolution.” He noted that previous experiments achieved only partial carbon-fixation chemistry, whereas this study shows full cellular growth.
Limitations and Next Steps
While the findings are compelling, the team acknowledges limitations. Lab conditions cannot capture the full complexity of natural vents, where metal concentrations, fluid flow and microbial diversity vary widely. Moreover, M. jannaschii represents only one lineage of acetyl CoA users; future experiments will examine bacteria such as Acetobacterium woodii and other archaeal species to determine whether the results generalize across domains.
The researchers also plan to introduce additional variables—varying pH, adding trace elements like nickel and cobalt, and testing different mineral compositions—to refine understanding of which conditions most strongly promote early metabolic pathways. High-pressure reactors will simulate deeper vent conditions, while isotope-labeling studies aim to trace carbon flow and reaction kinetics in real time.
Broader Significance for Astrobiology and Earth Sciences
Beyond illuminating Earth’s own history, this work has profound implications for astrobiology. Ocean worlds like Jupiter’s moon Europa and Saturn’s moon Enceladus harbor subsurface liquid water and are thought to host hydrothermal activity. If iron-sulfide chimneys can catalyze life’s first reactions on Earth, similar chemistries might spark life elsewhere in the solar system.
Dr. Sandra Nguyen, an astrobiologist at MIT, commented, “These results bolster the prospect that life could arise in extraterrestrial environments with hydrothermal vent analogues. Our instruments for future missions should target mineralogical signatures of mackinawite and greigite, as well as detect molecular hydrogen fluxes.”
On Earth, understanding ancient chemistries helps geologists interpret the earliest rock record. The team’s demonstration that archaea preferentially colonize iron-sulfide precipitates suggests that some of the oldest stromatolite-like structures may indeed represent fossilized microbial communities. Geochemical markers—such as specific sulfur isotope ratios—could further validate these interpretations.
Conclusion: From Chemical Gardens to Living Trees
By successfully recreating primordial hydrothermal chimneys in a lab and sustaining microbial life within them, Helmbrecht and colleagues have taken a major step toward solving one of science’s greatest mysteries: the transition from nonliving chemistry to biology. The iron-sulfide “gardens” once dismissed as mere curiosities now stand revealed as natural reactors, nurturing life’s first metabolic sparks.
As the research continues, combining geochemistry, microbiology and planetary science, humanity moves closer to tracing the full arc from simple chemical reactions in the deep sea to the astonishing biodiversity of the modern world. In the words of the authors, “Mackinawite and greigite chemical gardens provide a plausible cradle for early life, environments that could maintain continuous metabolic evolution until life emerged.” From the timeworn depths of ancient oceans to cutting-edge laboratory vials, the story of life’s beginnings unfolds—rooted in the heat, pressure and elemental alchemy of Earth’s primordial hydrothermal gardens.
