Hours after being deported from Israel, climate activist Greta Thunberg accused the Israeli government of “kidnapping” her and the eleven other passengers aboard the UK-flagged aid vessel Madleen. In a press conference at Paris’s Charles de Gaulle Airport, Thunberg insisted that she and her fellow volunteers had done nothing illegal while sailing in international waters to deliver humanitarian relief to Gaza. The activists were intercepted 200 kilometers off the Gaza coast on Monday and towed to Ashdod, where some remain in custody awaiting deportation hearings.
Background: The Freedom Flotilla Coalition and the Gaza Humanitarian Crisis
Since 2007, Israel has maintained a naval blockade on Gaza, restricting the movement of goods and people to and from the territory. In response to the growing humanitarian emergency—exacerbated by an eleven-week siege that aid agencies warn has pushed Gazans to the brink of famine—a loose alliance of civil society organizations known as the Freedom Flotilla Coalition has repeatedly attempted to challenge the blockade. Their vessels carry food, medical supplies, and other essential items for distribution by the U.S.-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which operates a handful of guarded aid distribution points within Gaza.
Despite those efforts, aid deliveries have been limited: fewer than 20 percent of requested food parcels reached Gaza in recent weeks, according to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). Dozens have been killed while queuing for rations, and thousands injured in crushes or struck by stray munitions as civilians scramble for scarce supplies.
The Madleen Voyage: A Symbolic Humanitarian Mission
The latest mission culminated in the deployment of the Madleen, a repurposed yacht chartered under the British flag. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition partnered with Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation in Tokyo, screening interested volunteers and loading the vessel with:
- 500 food packages (including high-energy biscuits and legumes)
- 50 medical kits (dressings, analgesics, antibiotics)
- 20 water purification units
- Five potted olive saplings (a symbol of Palestinian resilience)
Among the crew were Greta Thunberg (Sweden), Rima Hassan (French MEP), Spanish activist Sergio Toribio, Egyptian-Swedish volunteer Fatima El-Sayed, and American academic Dr. Sarah Klein. The group intended to sail directly to Gaza’s coast—approximately 200 kilometers from Ashdod—and transfer supplies to local teams via rigid-hull inflatable boats.
Interception in International Waters
Shortly before the scheduled rendezvous time of 4:17 a.m. on Monday local time, Madleen’s live‐streamed telemetry showed its altitude reading suddenly drop to zero—an indication of a forced boarding rather than a controlled descent. Israeli Navy vessels intercepted the flotilla, deploying armed commandos who boarded the yacht without prior notice, citing enforcement of the blockade. Video footage captured the moment heavily armed soldiers rappelled onto Madleen’s deck under night-vision illumination.
The yacht was then towed to Ashdod port, 120 kilometers south of Tel Aviv. Volunteers reported being held below deck for eight hours before being disembarked and taken into police custody. Israeli officials alleged that the vessel had “deliberately attempted to breach the lawful maritime blockade” and that its passengers would face charges of illegal entry and impeding state operations.
Volunteers’ Accounts: “We Did Nothing Wrong”
On her emotional return to Paris, Thunberg told reporters:
“We were 12 peaceful volunteers sailing on a civilian ship carrying humanitarian aid on international waters. We did not break laws. We did nothing wrong.”
Thunberg said she had refused to sign a statement claiming she entered Israel illegally. “This is yet another intentional violation of rights that Israel is committing,” she insisted, vowing to continue advocating for Gaza until aid can flow unimpeded.
Spanish volunteer Sergio Toribio, deported alongside Thunberg, echoed her sentiments in Barcelona:
“It is unforgivable…a pirate attack in international waters,” he said, describing the interception as an illegal act of aggression against unarmed humanitarians.
Legal and Human Rights Framework
Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), ships flying a flag—such as the UK flag—retain the right of peaceful passage through international waters. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition contends that their activities qualify as peaceful humanitarian operations, protected under international law.
Amnesty International weighed in with a statement from Secretary General Agnès Callamard:
“Interception of the Madleen in international waters, without warning and without legal basis, violates international law. The crew must be released immediately and unconditionally.”
The legal center Adalah, representing several detained crew members in Israeli courts, has filed habeas corpus petitions arguing that the interception breached both UNCLOS and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which guarantees freedom of expression and assembly.
Israeli Government’s Position
In Ashdod, the Israeli Foreign Ministry issued a brief statement:
“The Madleen deliberately attempted to breach Israel’s lawful naval blockade of Gaza, which has been in place since 2007 for security reasons. Boarding and detaining the vessel was a lawful measure. Volunteers will be processed in accordance with Israeli law.”
Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked appeared on Israeli television to defend the operation, stating, “No one is above the law. We have a right to enforce our blockade to prevent weapons smuggling to Hamas.” She refrained from addressing allegations that humanitarians are entitled to special protection under international law, focusing instead on the blockade’s security rationale.
International and Diplomatic Reactions
European Union High Representative Josep Borrell called for calm and a “de-escalation of tension,” urging Israel to allow humanitarian aid to Gaza. The EU Parliament passed a resolution condemning the interception and demanding immediate release of the volunteers.
In Washington, State Department Spokesperson Ned Price said the U.S. was “seeking clarification” from Israeli authorities. While reaffirming Israel’s security concerns, he stressed that “peaceful humanitarian efforts should not be treated as criminal acts.”
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan denounced the operation as “naval piracy against unarmed aid workers,” recalling the 2010 Mavi Marmara raid that killed nine activists. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa described the interception as “a disgrace to international norms” and intimated that Pretoria might raise the issue at the International Court of Justice.
Humanitarian Context: Gaza on the Brink
The Gaza Strip, home to 2.4 million Palestinians, has faced a de facto total blockade of goods since March. The U.N. World Food Programme warns that 60 percent of Gazans are undernourished, with rates of acute hunger soaring among children. Hospitals run out of medicines, and 80 percent of groundwater supplies have turned saline, making bottled water a scarce commodity.
Until now, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation—managed by U.S. and U.N.-affiliated agencies—has distributed only 15,000 food parcels weekly, far short of the 200,000 estimated necessary to prevent widespread famine. Volunteers aboard Madleen carried just 500 food packages—symbolic, but intended to highlight the dire aid shortfall.
Legal Proceedings and Detention Status
Eight crew members who declined immediate deportation—including Palestinians, European nationals, and a U.S. citizen—remain detained in Ashdod’s immigration facility. Israel’s Interior Ministry will hold deportation hearings on June 13. Defense lawyers from Adalah and the Israeli Bar Association have filed motions to challenge the grounds for detention and to bring charges before a civilian court rather than summary administrative proceedings.
Rima Hassan, the French MEP and international lawyer aboard Madleen, has sought parliamentary immunity from deportation, citing her status as a public figure on official legislative business. Israeli authorities have acknowledged her appeal but have not yet ruled on its merits.
Next Steps for the Freedom Flotilla Coalition
Despite the setback, the Freedom Flotilla Coalition has vowed to continue its maritime aid efforts. Spokesperson Anna Tarifa announced plans for a third mission:
“We will not be deterred by this interception. Our next ship will depart within months, better equipped and with international observers on board.”
The Coalition is also coordinating with major human rights organizations to document alleged abuses by Israeli forces, hoping to pursue lawsuits in European courts under universal jurisdiction statutes.
Public Solidarity Campaigns
Social media has erupted with the hashtag #FreeTheFlotilla. In Europe, solidarity rallies took place in Paris, London, and Berlin, where activists marched to Israeli embassies demanding the release of the detained volunteers and an end to the blockade. A petition on Change.org garnered over 500,000 signatures within 24 hours.
Conclusion
The arrest and deportation of Greta Thunberg and her fellow volunteers has thrust the Gaza humanitarian crisis back into global headlines. As Israel defends its naval blockade on security grounds, human rights organizations and many world leaders argue that peaceful aid operations in international waters are protected by law. With deportation hearings looming and widespread public outcry, the legal and diplomatic fallout promises to intensify. For Gaza’s starving population, each day without sufficient aid brings them closer to famine, underscoring the urgency of resolving this maritime standoff.
As detention hearings approach on June 13, eyes around the world will be on the Israeli courts and government to see whether they uphold the principles of free passage and humanitarian relief—or double down on a blockade that critics call a form of collective punishment. In the waters off Gaza, where every wave carries both hope and peril, the fate of the Madleen and its crew has become emblematic of a much larger struggle for human rights, security, and solidarity.
READ MORE: California Sues Trump Administration Over National Guard Deployment Amid Immigration Protests
